A Martial Art School For My Kid has Been Found

After rejecting 3 McDojos near our home, we ranged further and discovered a Kung Fu school we feel good about sending our 8 year old daughter to.

Its a very small school and the kid’s class only has 6 students.  The sifu is in his late 50’s and experienced in Wing Chun, JKD, and Kali.  He’s a former professional full contact fighter and has trained lots of kick-boxers, MMA fighters, and a few celebs.

What’s interesting is he is not teaching the kids in forms for the time being.  He is training them like fighters.  Lots of different drills to build their speed, endurance, and hand-eye coordination.  The kids love it.  His classes are totally informal and there is no uniform.   The best part is it costs about $30-40 less than the Mcdojos wanted.

Unfortunately, he doesn’t offer any classes late enough at night for my wife to participate.  So our search continues.  I have trained twice now with a very talented master in JKD and Escrima but he is out of town frequently and can’t conduct regular classes.  He also does combative Tai Chi and we’re both going to meet with him to try this out.  It may be a good art for my wife to learn while she is pregnant.

Martial Arts Intermission

Well, we got moved and now we’re in the dreaded unpacking phase.  Most of the time I’m too busy to think about martial arts but when I do have a little down time, I find my self missing class and my teachers greatly.

We haven’t begun looking for a new school in ernest but anytime we see a sign for karate or martial arts we do the slow, gawking drive-by.

In the meantime, we have som MA reading we can catch up on as well as a stack of DVDs on moddern arnis, ryukyu kenpo, and taichi that we can work on.  I’m veiwing it as sort of an academic sabbatical.

The time away from class will be good for me because I can focus on getting better at a variety of techniques important to me rather than on prepping for my next test or teaching kata to 8 year-olds.  Starting next week I’m going to try to get our family on a regular martial arts practice time here at home so we don’t get rusty or out of shape.

The 2 nearest schools to us are a McDojo (supposedly Shaolin kungfu via big California dojo chain) and a little TKD school.  Its not that I dislike TKD as a rule but there seems to be a lot of emphasis on high kicks and neither my wife nor I are really built for high kicking.  I realize any kata can be adapted to fit a body type but that doesn’t mean that adaptation will be acceptable by your teacher.

Still, it looks like an OK place to have our kid go (she can kick way higher than either of her parents).  While TKD is not my first or even 5th choice, I’ll do that rather than do nothing.  I like having a formal class and a place to practice and interact with other martial artists.

My Final Class and Test

The other night was my last class for my daughter and I at our martial arts school because we are moving.

She started there 3 years ago and while I didn’t actually start taking classes til much later, I was very involved with the school, the students, parents, and assisting the master.  That school and the people there are what I’ll miss most about this place.  I got so much out of my experience with it and it made living in a city we were never really thrilled to be in easier to tolerate.

So on my last night we both tested.  My daughter for her red belt with black stripe and me for brown.  I had to perform 2 katas as I was getting caught up and past due for testing.  The friend and teacher who conducted the self-defense portion of my test forgot about the shoulder I keep re-injuring and I had to do a drop-shoulder throw from a rear choke hold and that was very painful.  Still, overall it all went fairly smoothly.

Then came a surprise.  Before giving us our belts, the master of our school thanked me in front of everyone for all the help I have given him over the past three years and presented me with a set of three Japanese swords.  I was very moved and greatly appreciated the recognition.  He also presented my daughter with a pair of Chinese fans.  It all made for a great night and a memorable farewell.

My school is far from perfect and there is much room for inprovement.  But whatever its shortcomings, it helped our entire family discover our love for the martial arts and started us on our journey and for that we are grateful.

We don’t know where we’ll be training in our new city or even what style, but we will find people to help us continue to grow and improve in our martial arts and hopefully build the same kind of friendships we had in our old school.

Jujistsu For Women?

Ran across these informational videos from what I’m guessing is the 1930’s or 1940’s on jujitsu for women’s self-defense. (Whoever titled the videos obviously doesn’t know talkies didn’t arrive til the mid-1920’s and sound in film didn’t become commonplace til the mid-30’s)

On one hand, they are kinda condescending towards women but at the same time its a minor miracle they got made at all in that time period.  They’re just another intersting little nugget of modern martial arts history.

That last fall looked painful…


I love the scenario set-ups…

Variations On Double Knife Hands

I’m fascinated with the variations on martial arts moves from one style to another and even one school to another.

A good example is one night in our informal class we got to talking about how to perform a double knife hands strike/block.  In PaSaRyu this move is known as SooDo Bahng Auh, I don’t know what term is used for it in other arts.

The people there had come from various MA backkgrounds including TKD, Shotokan, PaSaRyu, and RyuKyu Kenpo.  Between everyone there were 4 different ways people had been taught to do the double knife hand:

1.   Back and Down: Hands start extended behind you and down at a 45 degree angle (roughly) and then fold up into the block/strike

2.  Back and Straight Out: Hands start extended straight out behind you, parallel to the floor, and then fold out forward into the block/strike

3.  Circling: Hands start extended behind you and down at a 45 degree angle (roughly) and then they circle up and over the head and come down in front of you

4. Compact: Calling it that for lack of better term.  Hands start out held close to your side, the backs of the hands touching, lead hand on top, and then fold out forward as wrists rotate into the block/strike.

What The 4 Ways Had In Common

There were a few points that all seemd to share.  First, is that the move is done from a cat stance.  Second, they all seemed to end up with the palm of the lead hand facing the opponent and the palm of the rear hand facing up.  The “why” of these commonalities was more complicated.

Practicality

We spent some time discussing which method we liked and what some of the practical applications of each methods might be.   It seemed to come down to how you interpreted the move.  Is it a block?  Is it a strike? Is it grappling?

My wife and I were originally taught it was a block.  We just accepted that at face value since it was coming from a 5th Dan.  But we’ve learned to question a lot of what we’ve been told moves are for.  A lot of the potential use for the move can be postulated from where it falls in a kata.  For example, in Choong Mu, I’m convinced the first use of the double knife hands is a grapple/throw, not a strike or block.  But in a kata like Pinan Shodan where there’s like 7 DKHs, I’m not so sure what the intention is.  But its fun guessing.

The Lesson Learned

I think what we all walked away from that discussion with was the idea that, there might be an “official” way of performing any particular move in your school or system or style that is necessary for you to pass a test, but that doesn’t make it the only way, nor necessarily the best way, for every situation in a real fight.

In class I will learn and perform techniques the way my teacher tells me to out of respect.  But outside of class, I will explore other ways, I’ll seek out contrary opinions, I will question everything that I’ve been told, and in the end, I think that will make me a better martial artist.  I’m lucky I have friends and mentors I can do this with.  Traditionalists may not like that attitude but I’ve never been a big fan of tradition for the sake of tradition.

As to the double knife hand, I’d like to hear how you were taught to do this move and what the point of the move is.  If you were told its a strike, what is the target?  If a block, what are you blocking exactly and why use this block?  If grappling, what are you grappling and what is the purpose of the move? Have you ever even been told why the move is in a kata at all? And regardless of the move’s purpose, what stance do you do it in and were you told why that stance?

Modern Arnis Test Results

…see previous post for background: Here Comes Testing Weekend

Nothing like testing to bring your ego back down to Earth.  None of the grandmaster’s black belts made it into town for the seminar so the grandmaster did all the testing himself.  I quickly learned that moves I thought I had all but mastered I was performing incorrectly or in a sub-par manner.  My foot-work also sucked big time.  All of us afterward felt we had performed poorly.  We choked. My wife and I both felt we had let our master down.  We really did not want to embarass him by performing badly with the GM.  The GM said he would watch us during the seminar the next day and then let us know our rank.

Since for most of his students Modern Arnis is a complimentary or secondary art, he decided a long time ago to not issue ranks as belts but simply as 10 kups (gup/geups/kyu) and then black belt.  He didn’t see the need to cause confusion as to who where’s what belt when, where, etc.  Belt is only issued at Black Belt and the black belt is actually black with a red stripe through the middle and is worn knotted on the side of the waist instead of the front (wearing it sideways keeps the belt from getting tangled in the sticks which I can vouch happens).  Our GM is a really humble man and he doesn’t need his students to feed his ego.  Personally, if I attain BB’s  in Modern Arnis and some other art, I would wear the Arnis Belt as it is the art I  have the most love for.

So anyway, the 2 hours we spent with the GM on friday night was testing and also a private training session which was very cool and enlightening.  At one point, a boy wandered up to us and said he wanted to learn how to fight with sticks.  The GM handed him a stick and shoved him at me.  I didn’t mind and I thought it would help keep him out of the way as we were being tested.  Later my master told me the GM did that because he wanted to watch and see what and how I taught the boy.  It became part of my test.

The seminar the next day was great, we had a good time and learned a few things.  After the 5-hour seminar everyone went out to dinner.  Someone at the seminar decided he wanted to test since the GM was there so after dinner, those of us who had tested the night before went with the GM back to the dojo.  We spent another 2 hours working with the GM.  All in all, outside of the seminar we got to spend 4 hours training in a concentrate setting with an exceptionally talented, patient, and humble man who deserves his rank of grandmaster and I count myself fortunate.

At the end of the night, we were given our rank.  Our newest member got 10th.  Me and my 3rd danPaSaRyu instructor got 8th.  My wife got 7th!  She was surprised she ranked higher than the rest of us but I wasn’t.  She’s not as stiff as us guys, she flows better.  All of us guys were admonished for having the footwork of trees and for hitting too hard and going to fast.  Our GM’s motto is “slow is smooth and smooth is fast”.

I have to admit while I am happy for my wife, I wished I had ranked higher myself.  It served as a much needed wake-up call as to how much I need to work on the basics.

Still, I ranked as high or higher than 2 other guys who were much more experienced martial artists.  I have vowed that I am going to beat both of them to Modern Arnis black belt and to reach it at the same time as my wife.  Before this, I wasn’t really much of a belt chaser, if I got rank, great, if not, so be it. It was about the learning.  But this, I want the belt.  I know who my GM studied with.  I know what he himself is capable of.  He does not give away rank.  A belt from him will have real meaning to me and I know what it will mean to people who are part of our greater MA circle.  His black belts are really respected.   I also want to make it all the way to BB so that I can make my master, the man who introduced me to Arnis, proud.   I want him to be proud of me and my wife and I want the GM to be proud of him.

What Is PaSaRyu?

We get asked this all the time because PaSaryu is not well known. Its an art mostly confined to the Mid-South region of the U.S. (TN, MS, KY, AR) mostly due to the fact that Master Kang Rhee, the founder of PaSaRyu, has his school in Memphis, TN.

Kang Rhee came to the U.S. in 1964 and founded PaSaRyu Mu Do.   His pedigree, if you care about such things (I personally don’t), is as follows:  he studied Chang Moo Kwan under Master Nam Suk Lee (1953-1956) and Kang Duk Kwon under Master Chul Hee Park (1957-1964).  I’m not sure of any connection but I have seen a photo of Rhee together with Bruce Lee and Chuck Norris.  I’m not sure of Kang Rhee’s current rank but I know he attained Seventh Dan Kuk Ki Won in 1975 (at Seoul’s TKD HQ).

Over the years Grandmaster Rhee has had a few famous individuals study under him including Bill “Superfoot” Wallce and Elvis Presley (who was apparently referred to Rhee by Ed Parker).

There’s a whole self-improvement and social responsibility philosophy as well but I’m not well-versed in it and honestly don’t have much interest in it.

Ok, that’s the basic background.  Now here’s what most people really want to know: what’s the PaSaRyu style like?

Basically, its a hybrid of Karate and Taekwondo performed with Kung fu influences.  The katas come from both Karate, like the pinans and heians, and TKD, like Choong Mu.   Katas are not performed using TKD’s “sine wave” or the metronome-like pace of karate.  The katas are performed in a more dynamic manner of fast and slow, hard and soft.  Master Rhee also teaches Tai Chi and yoga and suspect they have influenced how he sees kata.  I’ve had Karate guys watch a kata and recognize it as a pinan or whatever remark that they had never seen it done “like that”.

Stances are performed VERY low and wide.  The terminology used, as best I can tell, is the same as used in Kuk Sul and not TKD but I’m hardly an expert on Korean martial arts.

Testing is based pretty much on kata technique (individual, two-man, and weapons).  In order to advance you do not have to do any sparring, breaking,  or competing.  You do not have to be able to demonstrate any self-defense techniques.  PaSaRyu is great if you love doing kata and want to get into shape and improve your strength.  If you want to learn practical self-defense, I would look elsewhere.

PaSaRyu does have its own tournaments which include padded sparring, weapons kata, and creative routines.  PaSaRyu students also participate in TKD and Karate tournaments, at least on a local level.

Weapons taught at PaSaRyu schools include the usual suspects:  bo, chucks, kama, cane, sai, tonfa.  The weapons katas I have seen and learned tend to have a flashier XMA feel to them rather than practical fighting application but that may be more an influence from my school’s master and not indicative of all PaSaRyu schools.

Usually if someone asked the generic question of what style of martial art we study we just say Karate instead of getting into the lengthy explanation.

Like any martial art, there are those who love the style and those who scoff at it.  Personally, I’m glad I did it as my first art because I feel like I got an intro to several arts at once.  I like how the katas are performed from a aesthetic perspective, its more interesting to perform and watch being performed.  But the performance of the kata and the explanation of the purpose of the moves…well, lets just say I’ve been shown much more convincing explanations.

Some other things you run into with PaSaRyu is that being centered in the Mid-South, it is not that unusual for the schools to have an open “Christian” element to classes including things like concluding class with a prayer.  I don’t think this is a Kang Rhee thing, I thinks its a Southern thing.  I never really got the combination of martial arts and Christianity simply because it seems that turning the other cheek and learning to kick a cheek would be in conflict, but what do I know?

Another thing about PaSaRyu is it is not unusual to see weapons introduced as early as orange belt.  I don’t think this is so much a martial philosophy as it is a way to attract younger students.

One last thing about PaSaRyu students is the use of the word “Sun”.  Its used to acknowledge a good performance, as a congratulation on an achievement, a sign of respect to higher ranks, or as a way of acknowledging understanding.  At tournaments, a competitor will probably yell “Sun” 4 or 5 times as a sign of respect to the judges and to acknoledge their instructions.  The judges will say “Sun” to show appreciation of a competitor’s performance and and as a return sign of respect.

So there you have it in a nutshell.  The pedigree is based on official PaSaRyu publications.  The rest is based on my own experience over the past three years with our PaSaRyu school, our attendance of local PaSaRyu tournaments, and discussions I’ve had with a number of PaSaRyu black belts.  Its not necessarily indicative of others experience with the art.  I’ve heard and read praise and critiques of the art by others and all I can say is that the quality and value of any art to an individual is extremely subjective so feel free to express your opinions on it, or any other art for that matter.

Here Comes Testing Weekend

We’ve each got 2 tests this weekend.

She’s testing for her blue belt in PaSaRyu and her first belt test in Modern Arnis.

I’m testing for my yellow belt in Ryukyu Kempo and my first belt test in Modern Arnis.

The Modern Arnis test is a little different than what most people do. Because the practioners that follow Master Chiu are so spread out, they usually only come together a few times a year.  At those times, you test if you or your instructor feel you are ready.  Tests have nothing to do with how long you’ve been doing it, only on your ability level- what do you know how to do and how well can you do it.  So its my understanding that what will happen is we will take turns working with black belts who will be evaluating how we do and then we’ll work with Master Chiu.  After that he will ask the black belts for their assessment of our performance, weigh that against his own assessment and then he assigns us a belt rank.

Now when I say “work with” I mean spar with sticks and demonstrate things like stick-on-stick and empty-hand disarms.  We demonstrate what we know how they see how far and fast they can push us.  Its both intimidating and fun.  Because testing is only done a few times a year and is based on ability, the master will assign you your rank on based on ability and so he can choose to have you skip lower belts if you merit it.  In other words, your first time testing doesn’t mean you automatically get stuck in as a white or yellow belt.

While you get assigned rank of a certain belt color, there are no actual belts presented until you reach black belt.  No real uniform either.  You get a certificate and that’s about it.  Its not about chasing a physical symbol of your level for status.  Its about the gratification of knowing what you’ve managed to achieve based on the honest assessment of the black belts above you and the Master.   When it comes to Arnis, that’s the only recognition I need.  When I finally do reach black belt level, I’ll know that I really earned it based on what I can do, not on how much I’ve paid or how long I’ve been doing it.

Should Have Known Better

And the award for Dumb Move In The Dojo goes to….ME!

Long story short- learning forward shoulder rolls, me old and overweight:

POP! Holy $#!^!  My shoulder!

Diagnosis: 1st degree tear of assorted shoulder connective tissues and whatnot.

Prescription: rest, ice, painkillers

One week before I’m to test in Modern Arnis and Ryukyu, not to mention the 5 hour seminar.  Nice.

Hope I’m a fast healer.

Time is winding down.

We’re starting back up in PaSaRyu after holiday break today.

I got two beautiful new medium-weight gi’s (one red – my favorite color – and one black) for Christmas and I’ll alternate wearing them this week.  Who knows if I’ll wear a gi at all in our new art in LV?  Or if they’ll let me wear the ones I own?

I have a week left in PaSaRyu before I go to Las Vegas.

I’m scared, excited, sad and nervous at the same time.  I don’t want to leave the comfort zone – my first “martial arts home”.

I’m going to get as much as I can out of the next week.

–Her